Saturday, April 14, 2007

Buh-bye, Don Imus

Not being a fan of Don Imus, I can't say I'll miss his show, though the bald guy who did the impressions was very funny. I will say I've been both amused and disappointed at the publicity this incident has received, and especially at the number of intelligent people who have completely missed the point.

"Nappy-headed hos" is both racist and sexist, no matter what Imus says. But it is something more, and in my opinion, something worse. It's a bullying tactic, it's meant to be demeaning and oppressive. Imus has been claiming all week that he's a "nice guy". If he's is such a nice guy, how can he justify this kind of remark? He doesn't walk his talk. He spent half of each show patting himself on the back for his charity work, he never shut up about how much he did and what a great guy he was, and then claiming he wasn't trying to brag about himself. Of course he was. If he was such a nice guy, why does he need to remind everyone of that all the time? If he was really a nice guy, it would be self-evident.

He's tried claiming Snoop Dogg and others say much worse in their music. Excuse me, Imus, but didn't your mother ever ask you if Johnny jumped off a bridge, would you? YOU said it, YOU own it. Be a man and stop trying to shift the blame and focus to anyone else. He obviously has no idea whatsoever how his commentary stings and perpetuates the idea that it's ok to talk about women that way. I am so fed up of middle-aged white men telling me I don't have a sense of humor. Here's a clue for you assholes - walk a few miles in my shoes, grow up in a culture that only values women for their faces and their orifices, know that you could have the crap kicked out of you for speaking up just because someone else is physically bigger than you, learn that you aren't safe in parking lots or walking down the street, have a few kids and end up living in a shelter because the "man" has decided not to step up - go do some of that, then tell me how I don't have a sense of humor. Some men get it. Most do not. Imus is in the do not group. I don't understand why this culture of violence against those weaker than ourselves has become acceptable, but Imus has sure done his part to keep things status quo. If it isn't women, it's Jews or gays or fat people. Easy targets for cowards.

As for the free speech issue, it again misses the point. Does Imus have the right to say what he said? Sure he does. Does he have the right to say it on the public airwaves that my tax dollars support? Maybe. But does he have the right to a job spewing his ignorance and thoughtlessness? Absolutely not. He gets to accept the consequences of his right to free speech and he should shut up about it already.

Another defense that has been made is that Imus insults everyone. Are you people completely stupid? You really don't see the difference between going after a women's college basketball team based purely on their looks, and going after Dick Cheney, Hillary Clinton, the NY Knicks, or Deidre Imus? Even going after the men's college basketball team wouldn't be the same, since 99% of the men playing on one of the final four teams have multi-million dollar careers ahead of them playing a game. It isn't the same for the women. What would Imus think, I wonder, if Rush Limbaugh lit into a diatribe about Imus' kids at the ranch? How would that sit? And Imus is NOT a shock jock, hasn't been for years. I don't see national leaders and politicians going on Howard Stern's show, and Imus prides himself on those guests. He wants to have it both ways, or more to the point, HIS way. Well, too bad. Pick a side and live with your choice.

Imus may or may not be a racist. He is most certainly a sexist, but he is above all else a bully. He had a platform where he was far more influential than he should have been. Too many people get their news from the opinions of people like Imus, or Limbaugh, or even the Daily Show, and never bother to really look at an issue and form an independent opinion. The women of the Rutgers basketball team did not have access to a public forum like Imus does. They have Al Sharpton to thank for that forum, and Sharpton has also missed the point. For him, this is strictly a racial issue, and he isn't one to talk on that score. And who is he to accept Imus' apology? I'm still waiting to hear him apologize for calling those Duke students rapists, though I don't think he will. He's another wealthy asshole who is very quick to blame and just as quick to excuse himself. There is a word for people like Sharpton - HYPOCRITE. While I'm getting on Sharpton, I really resent how he has made these young women out to be victims. That didn't have to be the case, and they have showed a great deal of class in how they've handled this situation, but they could have, and I think would have, done better without Sharpton's interference. At least Jesse Jackson stepped aside when he was reminded of his own racist epithets.

As for Snoop, he's claiming his songs are about women who use the black man to get his money. LOL! MOST black men don't have Snoop's kind of money to go after. He's an idiot who hasn't read the studies and done the math. And even if his claim was true, where are his songs about the men who use women for sex, spread disease, get them pregnant, then take a hike? Well? C'mon, Snoop, what about that? Gutless wonder. Even more disappointing is that so many young women in this country think that music is "kewl". It isn't, but they aren't smart enough to think about the larger picture, they're too busy impressing their friends with their supposed broadmindedness and inclusiveness. The truth is they are being used, but by the time they are old enough to know better, they will have done their part to perpetuate the second-class citizenship of women to the next generation. Thanks, girls. Most of you are ghetto wanna-be's with no understanding of what that life is really like. Go do some volunteer work in the ghetto. Move to South Central LA or Harlem or Roxbury and live that life for a while, and stop thinking you understand because you've watched a few movies or videos on MTV.

I'm happy to have known men with real class and honor. Anhaga is a prime example. Cori is another. But honestly, those men are few and far between, and I'm too old to put up with any more crap from selfish, thoughtless, Y-chromosome afflicted dickwads just because they are bigger than me. No more. It isn't funny anymore.

14 comments:

  1. Sally Jenkins, a sports columnist for the Washington Post, published an article on Thursday, April 12 called "A Need Conversation." I liked it best of all the rants I've heard on the Imus thing. Here it is.

    I don't want Don Imus fired. Instead, I want him to buy season tickets to Rutgers women's basketball and sit in the front row wearing a sweat shirt with a big letter R on it at every home game.

    It serves no purpose to call for Imus's job; that's mere harsh vengeance and we've had enough undue harshness. If you shut down Imus's show, silence him, the conversation ends there. What's needed in the Rutgers-Imus affair, and on the subjects of racism and sexism in general, is not silence but talk, lots of it, and what's needed in women's basketball is a promoter. I know just the guy for the job.

    When Essence Carson took the microphone to speak for the Rutgers team, you saw Imus's problem and why it hasn't gone away. In comparison with that blameless face and voice, his slur seemed tangibly, specifically abhorrent, and you felt it all over again. How could any intelligent person conjure such verbiage as "nappy-headed hos" in the first place, much less apply it to such a nice kid? Carson and the Scarlet Knights didn't lecture, they didn't say that injustice is what happens when you treat someone as an abstraction, a stranger, an "other." Instead, they simply demonstrated the point by introducing themselves, one by one, and made clear that the central sin and fallacy in any -ism, whether racism or sexism, is that it fails to take into account the individual qualities of an Essence Carson.

    As Heather Zurich said, "What hurts the most about this situation is that Mr. Imus knows not one of us personally."

    It's only fitting, then, that Imus should have to get to know each and every player, learn the particulars of their characters and details of their lives, and one way to do that is to go to their games. Carson is a straight-A student, a classical pianist, a composed speaker and someone's child. "Before the student comes the daughter," she said. Point guard Matee Ajavon sat out for two months with a stress fracture and has a steel rod in her leg. Coach C. Vivian Stringer has surmounted a series of tragedies over her Hall of Fame career. Her daughter was crippled by spinal meningitis, and she was widowed early. "My heart has never been light in going to a Final Four," she said. "It took me personally 25 years to come to a championship game."

    Asked in a radio interview yesterday if she thought Imus was a racist, Stringer pointedly replied that she would wait to meet him in person before deciding.

    The Scarlet Knights have decided to meet Imus face to face. And personally, I believe it's the right thing to do. They aren't looking for a punishment that fits the crime, or to join a mob action, and they can reach their own conclusions without being stampeded by Jesse "Hymietown" Jackson into demanding Imus's resignation. They have a chance to get something more meaningful from him: a full-fledged conversion.

    To their credit, the Rutgers players seem to feel that it's no more right to paint Imus with a broad brush than it was to paint them with one. Imus seems sincerely ashamed of mouthing such unpardonable garbage, and it's legitimately hard to categorize him as an out-and-out racist. While I don't particularly know him, I've been on his show, and I listened to him champion Harold E. Ford Jr. during his run for U.S. Senate in Tennessee , and bitterly decry the slow government response to Hurricane Katrina. He's a shock-satirist who takes verbal baseball swings at piñata-size personalities for their pretensions, often as not powerful white people.

    But regardless of what anyone thinks of Imus, you don't cure prejudice by curbing speech. Clearly, as a society we've made the uneasy decision that censorship is more dangerous than sensitivity, otherwise Ann Coulter and Rush Limbaugh wouldn't get work. Words are hurtful, but for the most part they're inactive. Censorship is an action. As columnist John Leo succinctly put it, "No insults means no free speech."

    Just because words don't constitute acts, however, doesn't mean they're without effect, and that's where the Rutgers players have a chance to turn an evil incident into something beneficial. If nothing else, we've all learned that words aren't ephemeral, they hang around, in bits, texts and instant messages. Some things stay said. You can argue about whether Imus "scarred me for life," as Ajavon maintains, but he left a mark. The Rutgers kids assumed that the winner's circle was colorless and genderless, and Imus disabused them, abruptly, of that notion with one harsh sentence. He cost them that ideal. To a certain extent, he hardened their hearts, and he has to live with that.

    It's not frivolous, then, to suggest that one way for Imus to make amends to the Scarlet Knights is to use his microphone to promote and defend a deserving sport. Female ballplayers still fight enormous prejudice: They deal with a daily drumbeat of small degrading remarks, false assumptions and acts of stubborn little meanness; their looks and skills are derided; and at some schools they even have to fight for time on the practice court. An example: Back in 1998, when Tennessee Coach Pat Summitt was being celebrated for her sixth national championship -- her sixth, mind you -- she returned to campus and in the hallway of her own arena, she ran into an aging male administrator, who went out of his way to insult her. He stared at her coolly. "Did you win?" he asked. It was his way of telling her it wasn't worth watching.

    The truth is, the fallout from the Imus controversy is the most publicity the women's game ever has gotten. Some of the male sports columnists who weighed in this week annually neglect the women's Final Four, and most of them failed to witness a single game in which Rutgers played.

    So how is the Rutgers team better served? By demanding Imus be fired, or by converting him into an ally and employing his powerful voice and platform? By silencing his microphone, or by engaging him in sustained and badly needed conversation about race and gender? By refusing his contrition, or by suggesting that he come and watch, close-up and firsthand, and get to know them and the game they love? Preferably, wearing a scarlet sweat shirt.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, that is an excellent column, and one I agree with wholeheartedly, I think I'll post this in the Mote.

    While I won't miss his show, I never thought Imus should be fired; in fact, I wouldn't have even suspended him, I would have wanted him to sit there and take the heat and be responsible. I like her idea of him going to those basketball games, too. Like I said, he's a bully because he can be, and he doesn't understand what his bullying does to the targets of his ignorance. I believe he's genuinely embarrassed, but I don't think that excuses him. He *should* be embarrassed, and he should embrace it now and learn something.

    As for painting Imus with a broad brush, there is no need, he's done that for us. His record speaks for itself.

    The Rutgers women made me proud. I hope their example is followed and doesn't get lost in the hype.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's the drugs... he's not alone in the field of idiots that are put on the air as an example of what drugs do to your mind.

    ReplyDelete
  4. LOL! Imagine the advert ... a photo of Imus and the tagline, "This is your brain on drugs."

    I'll tell you who I'm really happy to seen gone, and that's the junkie skinny bald guy who sat up in the booth, the one who disappeared a couple years ago for a month of rehab without letting anyone know he was going. I can't think of his name, but he was the living definition of a waste of oxygen. It's not that I have no sympathy for drug addicts, but don't come back from rehab as if you are the second coming and the font of all wisdom.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bernard McGuirk, that's the shithead producer's name. What an unbelievable asshole. How anyone ever thought he was funny is beyond me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Re not painting with the broad brush, there's a little distance between the kinds of character shown by the Rutgers women as well. The one - forgive me, I don't know names - that said "I know I'm not a ho," has been held up as a paragon and that's OK with me. But how about the one who said that this had scarred her for life? A little hyperbole there? or a kid who has no idea what she's saying? If someone calls you a name that's patently off the mark, even if it's on national radio, and even if your friends tease you about it, if you're eighteen years old here in media America, really, it's not that big a hit. You can take offense and feel insulted. But you're not exactly scarred for life.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Agreed, and that's exactly where I think Sharpton can take some credit. These women weren't victims until HE labeled them victims. Hopefully someone will point that out to her and with a little distance and perspective, she'll realize she isn't scarred, but maybe she's empowered.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sharpton? He's the real ho here, a nappy headed ho's what he is.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'll be interested to see if there is any fallout that lands on him. I'm hoping so.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Bad hair, bad manners, bad drugs, bad brains, bad breath. Hunter Thompson had more intelligence in comparison to the men that won't be named in the spotlight due to commercialism and poor value.
    The young women will not be scarred for life you are correct w & w in my humble opinion.
    The whole pushing of values by a bad man had them confused and dismayed. They alone could have gone on the warpath with Imus and done a show spot or two or three or more (which he may have been looking for) and spoke their (not anyone elses) minds as to his comments.
    And yes, the one girl did look like she was on an ether binge, stating in a fog like manner that she knew she was not a ho. There I said it! But she was most certainly just exhausted from all the hype and media, wanting to just get back to class studies. These are shy/smart young woman who finally hit the spotlight and with careful guidance will make the most of it! The coach did ramble on and on, which unnerved me, but she has never been put in such a pickle and tried very hard to drive her point home while having to defend her team. A speech that should have been addressed from a podium in a happy, congratulatory arena. In a spotlight that they themselves knew wouldn't be coming for a "girls basketball team". The very school they attend doesn't watch them play, only looking for stats for promo reasons.
    On another note: They are all very attractive and may not be noticed as such with the way of the world right now, but I guarantee,,, being tall, lithe, smart and available will be in their power soon. These will be lessons learned and good ones at that. My simple straw hat is off to them!

    ReplyDelete
  11. BTW.... That is exactly how Imus gets guests to come on his show.. ((Or did)) Insult first, lots of hype, rebuttal second, and it made some of his best shows. Him being made out to be a jerk many, many times. He did give spotlight to interests that were overlooked. If any good comes from this, he may be the one to thank. YIKES!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Y'all might be interested, and perhaps surprised, to know that the guys with whom I chat basketball 'n' stuff are all pretty up on - they follow and find exciting - women's college basketball. It's not as neglected, I surmise, as many think.

    ReplyDelete
  13. PopPop whines about NBA basketball all the time, how boring it has become, and he refuses to watch. I have tried for years to get him to watch women's bball, which I think is very similar to the more tactical game that was played in the NBA of the 1950's and 1960's. Far more interesting than the high-scoring dunkfests that pass for basketball in the NBA these days.

    ReplyDelete
  14. In a bit of sideways news, Don Ho, the entertainer whose vivid shirts, baritone voice and easygoing manner came to symbolize his native Hawaii to millions of visitors, died last night. He was 76.

    Talk about irony.

    ReplyDelete